Guides · Scoring guide

Gimmes, mulligans and max scores.

What the Rules of Golf and the World Handicap System say about conceded putts, do-overs, double par and picking up, and what you can still post.

November 6, 2026

A gimme is legal in only one form of golf, and a mulligan in none, unless you count it. The Rules of Golf let you concede a putt only in match play, and they treat a second ball off the tee as your third shot. Everything else your group does on a Saturday morning is a house rule.

House rules are fine. The trouble starts when nobody agrees them before the first drive, or when someone posts a round played under them for a handicap.

The short answer

Gimmes (conceded putts) exist only in match play, under Rule 3.2b; in stroke play you must hole out on every hole. A mulligan isn’t allowed under the Rules: hit another ball from the tee and it’s stroke and distance, one penalty stroke, and the new ball is in play. A max score such as double par is a house rule, or the Maximum Score format of Rule 21.2 when a Committee sets one.

If you’ll post the round for your handicap, keep the real number. A hole you didn’t finish for a valid reason goes in at your most likely score, never more than net double bogey. A round with a free mulligan generally isn’t acceptable for posting at all.

Agree it all on the first tee

An argument about scoring on the 14th green is usually about something nobody said on the 1st tee. Settle these before anyone hits:

  • Is anyone posting this round? Ask this first; the answer settles most of the rest.
  • Gimmes: how close, and do they count in the bets as well as on the card?
  • Mulligans: none, one on the first tee, or one a side?
  • A maximum score: double par, a fixed number, or net double bogey?
  • Out of bounds and lost balls: back to where you played from, or the two-stroke drop of Model Local Rule E-5?

That takes thirty seconds, and it leaves you with scores you can compare at the end.

Gimmes: match play’s privilege

A gimme is a concession, and Rule 3.2b gives concessions to match play alone. You can concede your opponent’s next stroke, a hole or the whole match, out loud or with a clear gesture, and once given it can’t be declined or taken back. Our match play guide covers how they work in a match.

Stroke play has no such thing. Rule 3.3c makes you hole out on every hole, and if you don’t, you must go back and finish before you tee off on the next one, or before you hand in your card after the last. Otherwise it’s disqualification.

Agreeing to give each other gimmes in a stroke-play competition is worse still. Under Rule 1.3b(1), players who agree to ignore a Rule or penalty they know applies are disqualified, even before they act on the agreement.

In a casual round there’s no Committee to disqualify anyone, and plenty of groups give each other the short ones to keep moving. That’s their call, but the card stops being a stroke-play score, and if you want to post it, the handicap rules stretch only so far.

Rule 3.3 of the Rules of Handicapping covers a hole you started but didn’t hole out for a valid reason, such as a putt conceded in match play, a partner’s better score in four-ball, or having already reached net double bogey. You record your most likely score: the strokes you’d taken plus the strokes you’d most likely need to finish, never more than net double bogey. A tap-in your friends waved away in a stroke-play round isn’t one of the examples. Our stance: if you’re posting the round, putt it.

Mulligans: count them

Most accounts trace the name to David Mulligan, a part owner of New York’s Biltmore Hotel, who hit a second ball after a bad opening drive at St. Lambert Country Club in Montreal in the 1920s; his regular foursome made a first-tee do-over an unwritten rule. A rival story credits Buddy Mulligan, a locker room attendant at Essex Fells in New Jersey, in the 1930s. Either way, the Rules have no do-overs. They have stroke and distance.

Under Rule 18.1, you may at any time add one penalty stroke and play again from where you played your last shot. Once that ball is in play, the first one isn’t, even if it turns up in the middle of the fairway. So a “mulligan” off the tee, counted properly, is your third shot.

The one ball the Rules let you hit without giving up the first is a provisional (Rule 18.3), and only when your first might be lost outside a penalty area or out of bounds. You have to announce it first, using the word “provisional” or otherwise making that clear. “I’ll hit another” isn’t enough; that ball is in play under stroke and distance.

A free mulligan, where you hit again, keep the better ball and add nothing, breaks the Rules. Count yours instead: with its penalty stroke added, a mulligan is a legal stroke-and-distance shot, the card stays honest, and you can still post the score, whatever your friends offered on the first tee.

Max scores and picking up

A maximum score per hole is the most useful house rule there is, because a 12 on a par 4 takes a long time to make. The Rules of Golf even have a format for it. In Maximum Score (Rule 21.2), the Committee sets a cap for each hole, such as twice par, a fixed number or net double bogey; you’re encouraged to stop once you reach it, and a hole you don’t finish scores the maximum. It’s one of the formats the USGA accepts for handicap posting.

For posting, the cap that matters is net double bogey: par, plus 2, plus any handicap strokes you receive on the hole. Until you have a Handicap Index, it’s par plus 5. The common pick-up rule, double par, against those caps:

ParDouble parNet double bogey, no strokeWith one strokeWith two strokesNo Index yet (par + 5)
365678
486789
51078910

For any golfer who receives no more than one stroke on a hole, which means a Course Handicap of 18 or less, double par sits at or above the posting cap, so picking up there costs your handicap nothing: the system would have counted the hole at net double bogey anyway.

Two groups are different. Golfers who receive two strokes on a hole, and golfers still building toward their first Index, can reach double par before their posting cap: on a par 3 with two strokes, and on par 3s and par 4s before an Index. If that’s you and you pick up, post your most likely score, not the double par.

Our advice: if you post, pick up at net double bogey. Reaching it is a valid reason to stop under the Rules of Handicapping, and it’s the number the system would use anyway, so nobody has to guess what you’d have made.

What you can post

A score is acceptable for handicap purposes when you play it by the Rules of Golf, with at least one other person, on a rated course in its active season (Rule 2.1 of the Rules of Handicapping). Casual habits sort out like this:

What happenedCan you post it?
Conceded putt in a matchYes, at your most likely score for the hole
Picked up after reaching net double bogeyYes, at net double bogey
Mulligan counted as stroke and distanceYes: it’s a legal score
Free mulligan, no penalty addedGenerally not
Out of bounds, dropped under Model Local Rule E-5 with two penalty strokesIt may still be acceptable, even where the course hasn’t adopted E-5
ScrambleNo

The free mulligan falls under Clarification 2.1b/3: in general play, a score where the player broke a Rule and knowingly didn’t apply the penalty generally shouldn’t be accepted, though the handicap committee can still accept it by recording that hole at its actual score, at net double bogey or at net par. The E-5 row comes from Rule 2.1b: following a Model Local Rule the course hasn’t adopted may still leave the score acceptable, at the committee’s discretion.

Scrambles never count, because nobody plays their own ball. Our scramble guide explains the alternatives.

Keeping the card honest

Write the number you took. If a house rule stopped you short, write the number you’d post.

Short Pencil has no X key. Every box takes a number from the keypad, which runs 1 to 10 with an 11+ key, so on a hole where you picked up, tap your most likely score. The circles and boxes then mean what they should, and the card in your round journal is one you could post from. The house rules printed at the foot of every Short Pencil card are the clubhouse four: replace divots, repair ball marks, rake bunkers, keep pace. The gimme range is yours to agree.

Next time you’re on the first tee, ask the posting question before anyone mentions a mulligan. Once you know who’s posting, every other house rule takes about ten seconds to settle.

Questions

What is a gimme in golf?

A short putt your opponent lets you pick up without playing it. The Rules call it a concession, and allow it only in match play (Rule 3.2b).

Are gimmes allowed in stroke play?

No. Rule 3.3c requires you to hole out on every hole in stroke play, and players in a competition who knowingly agree to give each other putts are disqualified under Rule 1.3b(1). In a casual round it’s a house rule.

What is a mulligan in golf?

An informal do-over, usually of a bad tee shot, without a penalty. The Rules of Golf don’t allow it. Hitting another ball from where you last played is stroke and distance: one penalty stroke, and the new ball is the one in play, even if the first turns up in the fairway. Only a provisional, announced first, keeps the original in play.

Can you post a score with mulligans?

Not if they were free: a score where you knowingly skipped a penalty generally isn’t acceptable. Count each one as stroke and distance and the score is legal.

What is the maximum score per hole in golf?

In stroke play there’s no maximum: you count every stroke. For handicap posting, each hole is capped at net double bogey, which is par plus 2 plus any handicap strokes you receive, or par plus 5 before you have a Handicap Index.

What does double par pickup mean?

A house rule, or a Committee’s choice in the Maximum Score format, that ends a hole once you reach twice its par: 6 on a par 3, 8 on a par 4, 10 on a par 5. If you post the round, record your most likely score on any hole where you picked up, never more than net double bogey.

Can you pick up and still post a score?

Yes, if you stopped for a valid reason, such as reaching net double bogey or a putt conceded in match play. Record your most likely score for that hole, never more than net double bogey.

More guides